Large Commercial & Industrial Standard Offer Quick Start Program
Program Manual - April 2008
QUICK LINKS
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PROGRAM OVERVIEW
“Quick Start” PROGRAMS TO REDUCE PEAK DEMAND
In September 2007, the Arkansas Public Service Commission (APSC) ordered all
investor-owned regulated utilities within Arkansas to offer energy-saving
programs to their customers. In Docket No 07-085-TF, Order No. 8, the APSC
approved the Entergy Arkansas, Inc. energy efficiency programs.
The first three years of the programs are called the “Quick Start” period.
During this time, Entergy Arkansas* is offering a variety of programs, which
are limited in nature, with the intention of gaining market knowledge and
preparing to potentially provide future programs to additional customers. As a
result, the programs are limited in scope, the funds available, and the number
of customers who may participate.
One of these approved Quick Start programs, the Large C&I Standard Offer Quick
Start Program, is detailed below.
LARGE C&I ENERGY STANDARD OFFER Quick Start PROGRAM OBJECTIVES
The Large Commercial & Industrial (C&I) Energy Standard Offer Quick Start
Program is an energy efficiency program designed for C&I customers who are 100
kW or greater. The program seeks to provide financial incentives for the
installation of a wide range of measures that reduce peak demand loads in
commercial and industrial facilities.
The program does not prescribe technologies or end uses but provides a
framework through which customers can receive $230/kW incentives for
installing a wide range of measures at customer facilities.
* Entergy Arkansas. Inc.
**Entergy Arkansas, Inc. does not guarantee or make any warranties or
representations regarding the services performed by any third parties,
including professionals provided by the program. Participating customers have
sole responsibility for reviewing and using the results or recommendations of
any services performed by such service providers.
Back to Top
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PROGRAM ELIGIBILITY
ELIGIBLE CUSTOMERS
The Large C&I Standard Offer Quick Start Program is offered to all Entergy
Arkansas retail electric customers that have a peak demand 100 kW or greater,
or at multiple facilities with a combined maximum demand of at least 250 kW.
A customer is defined by a single Tax ID number. Organizations with multiple
locations are thereby considered a single customer, regardless of how many
Entergy Arkansas account numbers they may have. See “Participation
Requirements” for additional information regarding affiliates.
NOTES
Entergy Arkansas will not directly market any energy efficiency-related
product or service to its customers. Entering into an agreement with Entergy
Arkansas does not imply Entergy Arkansas’ endorsement or approval of any
customer’s product or service. Entergy Arkansas makes no representation of the
benefits of any particular technology or energy efficiency measure eligible
for incentives under this program. The selection of an energy efficiency
measure is at the discretion of the individual customer.
Back to Top
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
INCENTIVES
WHAT IS THE INCENTIVE PRICING?
The incentives for eligible energy efficiency measures are based on $230/kW
for peak demand reductions.
INCENTIVE BASIS
Funding is available to pay incentives for qualifying energy efficiency
projects in Large Commercial & Industrial facilities.
Deemed Savings
Incentives are paid on the basis of deemed savings, which are standardized
savings values or simple formulas for a wide range of measures in
representative building types.
Measured Savings
If deemed savings have not been established for a particular qualifying energy
efficiency measure, then incentives are paid on the basis of verified peak
demand savings using the International Performance Measurement and
Verification Protocol.
FUNDING LIMITATIONS
To ensure incentives are available for multiple projects, no customer and its
affiliates may receive more than 20 percent of Entergy Arkansas' program
budget in any funding year. In addition, the program plans to reserve half of
the incentive funds for industrial customers and half of the incentive funds
for commercial customers. The program administrator may adjust this program
condition, if necessary, to ensure that the program meets the objective of
fully subscribing the incentive funds.
-
Customers are defined by a single Tax ID number. Organizations with multiple
locations are thereby considered a single customer, regardless of how many
Entergy Arkansas account numbers they may have. See “Participation
Requirements” for additional information regarding affiliates.
-
Customers may apply for the maximum incentive amount.
-
A customer may submit multiple applications and participate in multiple
projects, as long as the total incentive from all such projects does not
exceed the above limits.
HOW FUNDING IS RESERVED
Funds are reserved on a first-come, first-served basis.
HOW ARE INCENTIVES PAID?
Deemed Savings - One Payment
A project that only utilizes deemed savings to calculate peak demand savings
will receive an "Installation Payment" representing 100 percent of the total
estimated incentive payment after the project is installed, documented and
accepted.
Incentives are paid by check directly to the Entergy Arkansas retail electric
customer after the project is completed and verified (post inspected if
necessary). Checks will be delivered no later than December 31 of the payment
year.
Measured Savings - Two Payments
After the project is installed, documented and accepted, the customer will
receive an "Installation Payment" representing 40 percent of the total
estimated incentive payment.
For measured savings projects, Entergy Arkansas will use the following formula
to calculate the amount of the initial payment:
Installation Payment = [((estimated kW) * ($/kW incentive))] * 40%
After all measurement and verification activities are complete, documented and
accepted, the customer will receive the "Performance Payment" based on
verified savings (up to 60 percent of the total estimated incentive payment).
The second payment (the "Performance Payment") will be based on the one-year
energy savings the customer measures and documents in its Savings Report. The
Performance Payment may be up to 60 percent of the total estimated incentive
included in the C&I SOP Agreement and will be calculated as follows:
Performance Payment = [((measured kW saved) * ($/kW incentive))] -
Installation Payment
NOTES
Under no circumstances will Entergy Arkansas make a total incentive payment
more than 100 percent of the total estimated incentive payment specified in
the C&I SOP Agreement. No customer has an unconditional entitlement to the C&I
SOP incentive funds. In all cases, payment procedures and amounts specified in
the C&I SOP Agreement supersede this and any other documents.
Back to Top
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PARTICIPATION REQUIREMENTS
The Large Commercial & Industrial Standard Offer Program (C&I SOP) involves a
Program Administrator consisting of Entergy Arkansas and its implementing
contractor, CLEAResult Consulting. The program also involves qualified Entergy
Arkansas customers as described in the eligibility section.
PROGRAM ADMINISTRATOR
The Program Administrator’s responsibilities include:
-
Providing program outreach and marketing
-
Reviewing and approving or rejecting project applications
-
Performing certain inspection activities
-
Authorizing and issuing incentive payment
CUSTOMER
A customer:
A customer's responsibilities include:
-
Identifying potential project opportunities
-
Providing Entergy Arkansas access to project facilities both before and after
project completion for inspection of the baseline and post-retrofit condition
-
Completing the installation and commissioning of approved projects
-
Complying with mandatory progress milestones
-
Submitting implementation reports and invoices
In any funding year, no customer and its affiliates may receive more than 20
percent of Entergy Arkansas' C&I SOP program budget. Entergy Arkansas defines
an affiliate as:
-
A person who directly or indirectly owns or holds at least 5.0 percent of the
voting securities of the customer
-
A person in a chain of successive ownership of at least 5.0 percent of the
voting securities of the customer
-
A corporation that has at least 5.0 percent of its voting securities owned or
controlled, directly or indirectly, by the customer
-
A corporation that has at least 5.0 percent of its voting securities owned or
controlled, directly or indirectly, by:
-
a person who directly or indirectly owns or controls at least 5.0% of the
voting securities of the customer; or
-
a person who directly or indirectly owns or controls at least 5.0% of the
voting securities of the customer; or
-
a person in a chain or successive ownership of at least 5.0% of the voting
securities of the customer
-
A person who is an officer or director of the customer or of a corporation in
a chain of successive ownership of at least 5.0 percent of the voting
securities of the customer ;
-
A person who actually exercises substantial influence or control over the
policies and actions of the customer;
-
A person over which the customer exercises the control described in
subparagraph (F) of the paragraph;
-
A person who exercises common control over the customer , where "exercising
common control over the customer" means having the power, either directly or
indirectly, to direct or cause the direction of the management or policies of
the customer, without regard to whether that power is established through
ownership or voting of securities or any other direct or indirect means; or
-
A person who, together with one or more persons with whom the person is
related by ownership, marriage or blood relationship, or by action in concert,
actually exercises substantial influence over the policies and actions of he
customer even though neither person may qualify as an affiliate individually.
Back to Top
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PROJECT REQUIREMENTS
WHAT IS A PROJECT?
A project is defined by a set of proposed demand savings measures included in
a single application. Comprehensive projects that include a range of measure
types are encouraged.
All projects must meet the following requirements:
Minimum Project Size:
Each project must include a total estimated demand reduction of at least 20 kW
during the summer peak period, defined as between 11 a.m. and 9 p.m., Monday
through Friday, for the months of May through September, excluding holidays.
Multi-Site:
One project may involve the installation of measures at more than one customer
site, if the sites are similar. For example, installation of measures at a
chain of grocery stores may include more than one location but may constitute
a single project. Combining similar measures/sites into a single project
reduces administrative costs for performing due-diligence review of
applications and pre- and post-construction inspections.
ELIGIBLE ENERGY EFFICIENCY UPGRADE PROJECT MEASURES
The energy efficiency upgrade measures in the list below are based on deemed
savings and are eligible in the Large C&I Standard Offer Program.
The savings from these measures—based on the “Arkansas Deemed Savings Quick
Start Program Draft Report - Commercial Measures”—apply where no unusual
conditions exist. For example, chiller loads must not be more than 20 percent
process related, and projects must not incorporate significant deviations from
typical chiller operation practices (e.g. non-standard chilled water or
condenser water set points, ice production during off peak hours, changes in
chiller sequencing, etc.). These measures require no short-term testing or
long-term metering.
If a customer has a measure not specified in the list below or with unusual
conditions, such that the measure does not qualify for deemed savings, the
customer may choose to follow the requirements in the “Measurement and
Verification” section below.
1. LIGHTING EFFICIENCY
1.1. Lamp and Ballast Replacements
1.2. HID Fixture Replacements
1.3. Hard-Wired CFLs
2. PREMIUM EFFICIENCY MOTORS
3. UNITARY AC AND HP EQUIPMENT
3.1. Air Conditioners—Air Cooled
3.2. Air Conditioners—Water and Evaporatively Cooled
3.3. Heat Pumps—Air Cooled
4. WATER CHILLING EQUIPMENT (CHILLERS)
4.1. Screw—Air Cooled
4.2. Reciprocating—Air Cooled
4.3. Reciprocating—Water Cooled
4.4. Rotary/Screw/Scroll—Water Cooled
4.5. Centrifugal—Water Cooled
Measures are required to:
-
Produce demand savings through an increase in energy efficiency
-
Produce a measurable and verifiable electric demand reduction during the peak
summer period and must reduce electricity consumption
-
Have a useful life of 10 or more years
-
Exceed minimum equipment efficiency standards
EFFICIENCY STANDARDS
Entergy Arkansas has designed the Large C&I Standard Offer Program to
encourage electric energy efficiency projects. Accordingly, demand savings
credit will be allowed for new equipment that exceeds a relevant industry
minimum efficiency standard, where applicable. The equipment efficiency
standards listed below shall be enforced for projects submitted to the Large
C&I Standard Offer Program:
|
Equipment Table Type
|
Applicable Baseline
|
|
Standard
Cooling Equipment
|
IECC 2003 (minimum installed efficiency)
|
|
Lighting
Standard Fixture Wattage
Maximum building wide lighting power density in Watts/square feet
|
Retrofit – Based on 1992 EPACT and AR Standard Fixture Wattage Table
New Construction – ASHRAE 90.1-2001 Lighting Power Density and AR Standard
Fixture Wattage Table
|
|
Motor
Standard Efficiencies
|
EPACT 1992 (for motors less than 200HP)
|
INELIGIBLE MEASURES
Excluded from consideration in the program are measures that:
-
Receive an incentive through any other energy efficiency program offered by
Entergy Arkansas
-
Involve fuel switching
-
Involve self-generation or cogeneration
-
Rely on changes in customer behavior
-
Require no investment
-
Result in negative environmental or health effects
NOTES
If the customer pursues measures for which deemed savings values have not been
approved by the APSC, then the customer generally must follow the
International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP).
Entergy Arkansas will be the final authority on whether any particular measure
is eligible for incentives.
Back to Top
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PROGRAM PROCESS
Participation in the C&I Standard Offer Program involves five basic phases for
projects with measured savings (projects requiring M&V). The five phases
include:
-
Submitting an Initial Project Application (IPA) in order for Entergy Arkansas
to screen the project for measure and customer eligibility. If the IPA is
accepted, Entergy Arkansas reserves funds for the customer
-
Preparing and submitting a Final Project Application (FPA)
-
Entering into a Standard Offer Program Contract with Entergy Arkansas
-
Installing the project and submit an Installation Report (IR) to receive an
initial incentive payment (40% Installation Payment)
-
Conducting measurement and verification (M&V) activities and submit a Savings
Report (SR) in order to receive the final incentive payment (~60% Performance
Payment)
If the project is based on Deemed Savings, only the first four phases are
required, and payment will be 100 percent of incentives upon verification.
PROGRAM PROCESS DIAGRAM
INITIAL PROJECT APPLICATION
The first step in the C&I SOP process is for the customer to submit a
completed Initial Project Application (IPA) for its proposed project. The IPA
includes information about the customer, information about the schedule for
the sites at which the proposed project will be installed, the estimated kW
and kWh impacts, and an Initial Project Application Agreement.
Entergy Arkansas will begin accepting IPA's on an announced date and will
continue accepting applications until all funds have been reserved or until
the end of the program year, whichever is earlier
-
Submittal of Initial Project Applications will be via e-mail, followed by a
hard copy to the Program Administrator
-
IPA's will be considered on a first-come, first-served basis.
Initial Project Application Agreement
The IPA process requires the
customer to sign an Initial Project Application Agreement. The terms of this
agreement are standard for all customers and are not negotiable. Customers are
urged to review the IPA Agreement before submitting a project application. The
IPA Agreement is included on the final tab of the IPA.
Initial Project Application Review
Entergy Arkansas will review
each Initial Project Application (IPA) for customer and measure eligibility.
Entergy Arkansas may request clarification of, or additional information
about, any item submitted as part of the IPA.
-
Customers will have five days to respond to such requests.
-
If the clarification or additional information provided is not sufficiently
responsive, Entergy Arkansas may, at its sole discretion, request additional
information or discontinue its evaluation of the submittal.
Any customer submitting an unsuccessful Initial Project Application may
reapply for project funding by submitting another Initial Project Application.
However, the customer will lose its original position in the order of
submittal for reserving funds. If Entergy Arkansas approves the Initial
Project Application, the customer will be so notified, in writing.
Non-approval of an Initial Project Application
Entergy Arkansas
may not approve an Initial Project Application (IPA) if:
-
The IPA is incomplete
-
The IPA is received after all funding has been reserved
-
The customer fails to meet program eligibility requirements
-
The customer fails to submit the required supporting documentation
-
The customer is found to have made material misrepresentations in the IPA
-
The customer fails to comply with applicable federal, state and local laws and
regulations
-
Changes occur in laws or regulations directly affecting the C&I SOP
FINAL PROJECT APPLICATION In the second step in the C&I SOP process,
customers complete a Final Project Application (FPA). This application
describes the proposed measures, project sites, estimated demand savings and
estimated incentive payments based on a detailed engineering study and site
audit. This application includes the following information:
-
Detailed information about the customer site(s);
-
The existing and proposed retrofit equipment inventories, including equipment
counts, equipment efficiencies and equipment nameplate data;
-
Building occupancy and equipment operating schedules;
-
Engineering calculations estimating demand savings based on the efficiency of
the proposed equipment compared to that of new, minimum-standard efficiency
equipment;
-
For projects with measured (not deemed savings), a proposed project-specific
M&V plan describing how the customer will measure and verify demand savings,
the methods for calculating actual savings, and a schedule for conducting and
reporting on M&V activities. In some cases, pre-installation M&V activities
may be required to accurately estimate savings; and
-
Revised work plan for project design, implementation, operation and
management, including the anticipated project timeline.
Final Project Application Agreement
The FPA process requires the
customer to sign an Final Project Application Agreement. The terms of this
agreement are standard for all customers and are not negotiable. Customers are
urged to review the FPA Agreement before submitting a final project
application. The FPA Agreement is included on the final tab of the FPA.
Final Project Application Review
As part of the Final Project
Application review process, Entergy Arkansas will review the eligibility of
the proposed measures, the accuracy of the savings estimates, and the
comprehensiveness of the M&V plan. The Final Project Application must be
submitted within 45 days of the date of the IPA acceptance for lighting only
projects and within 100 days for all other projects in order to hold reserved
funding. Failure to submit the FPA within the day limit may result in loss of
reserved funding
-
Customers who do not meet the FPA deadline may re-file an Initial Project
Application for the same project, subject to availability of funds or the
existence of a project waiting list.
-
Entergy Arkansas may request clarification of, or additional information
about, any item in the application. Customers will have 10 days to respond to
such requests. If the clarification or additional information is not
forthcoming, Entergy Arkansas may choose to discontinue its evaluation of the
application.
Where FPA incentive estimates differ from the incentive funds reserved in the
IPA, the FPA savings and incentive estimates will take precedence over the
IPA, as the FPA should include a more detailed and accurate estimate of peak
demand savings.
-
Where FPA estimates are lower than those approved in the IPA, the reserved
incentives will be adjusted down accordingly, and excess incentive funds
returned to the remaining program incentive budget.
-
In some cases FPA estimates may be higher than approved in the IPA. If all
incentive funds have been reserved, and projects are on a waiting list, the
project will be limited to the funds reserved in the IPA.
Baseline Inspection
Entergy Arkansas will conduct a baseline
inspection of the project site after the C&I SOP Agreement is executed. The
purpose of the inspection is to verify the baseline conditions documented in
the Final Project Application. The baseline inspection requires the presence
of at least one customer representative who is familiar with the project and
the facility so that all parties can identify any discrepancies
simultaneously. The inspection will verify the following information:
-
All baseline equipment is still in place and operational; and
-
New equipment installation or old equipment demolition has not begun.
STANDARD OFFER AGREEMENT
The third step in the C&I SOP process is for the customer and Entergy Arkansas
to execute a Standard Offer Agreement outlining the terms and conditions for
the project. During the course of this C&I SOP, Entergy Arkansas will not
entertain proposed modifications to the C&I SOP Agreement. Applicants are
urged to review the C&I SOP Agreement prior to submitting a project
application. The executed C&I SOP Agreement must be returned to Entergy
Arkansas within 15 days.
VERIFICATION PERIOD
By no later than July 31, 2008, customers must verify in writing they will
meet their commitment to complete their projects by the end of the
implementation period.
IMPLEMENTATION PERIOD
The fourth step in the C&I SOP process is the Implementation Period during
which the customer installs the energy efficiency measures at the customer's
site. Installation must be completed by October 31 in the current funding
year. That is, projects receiving incentives from the 2008 budget must be
installed by October 31, 2008.
Installation Report
Customers must submit an Installation Report
(IR) within 30 days of completing installation. The Installation Report
updates any information proposed in the Final Project Application that has
been finalized after completion of the project. The IR typically includes the
following information:
-
The demolished and actual installed retrofit equipment inventories, including
equipment counts, equipment efficiencies and equipment nameplate data
-
Updates to building occupancy and equipment operating schedules
-
Updated engineering calculations estimating demand savings based on the
efficiency of the actual installed equipment compared to that of new,
minimum-standard efficiency equipment
-
A final project-specific M&V plan describing how the customer will measure and
verify demand savings, the methods for calculating actual savings and a
schedule for conducting and reporting on M&V activities
Post-Installation Inspection
Entergy Arkansas will contact the
customer to arrange a post-installation inspection of the project site after
receipt of a complete Installation Report. The post-installation inspection
requires the presence of at least one customer representative who is familiar
with the project and the facility. The inspection shall verify that:
-
The equipment specified in the Installation Report has been installed; and
-
The M&V plan (if not using deemed savings) is being followed in accordance
with the approved Final Project Application.
Installation Payment
Along with the Installation Report, customers
should submit an invoice in order to receive the installation payment. Entergy
Arkansas' Installation Report review cycle, including a post-installation site
inspection and invoice payment, is 30 days.
PERFORMANCE PERIOD
The fifth and final step in the C&I SOP process for projects with measured
savings is called the performance period. (A project that only utilizes deemed
savings to calculate demand savings will receive an "Installation Payment"
that represents 100 percent of the total estimated incentive payment after the
project is installed, documented, and accepted). During the performance
period, the actual demand savings resulting from the energy efficiency project
are quantified through measurement and verification (M&V) activities.
Savings Report
The time required to complete M&V activities will
range from less than a month up to 12 months, depending on the approach
chosen. Within 30 days of the completion of all M&V activities, the customer
submits a Savings Report (SR) documenting the project's measured and verified
demand savings.
Performance Payment
In conjunction with the SR, the customer
should submit an invoice for the final incentive payment - the Performance
Payment. This payment is based on the project's verified savings minus the
amount paid in the Installation Payment. The total incentive payment
(installation payment plus performance payment) cannot exceed the incentive
payment listed in the Final Project Application. Entergy Arkansas' Savings
Report review cycle, including invoice payment, is 30 days.
NOTES
If any of the baseline equipment at a project site has been removed prior to
the execution of the C&I SOP Agreement, or if any of the proposed
energy-efficient measures have been installed prior to the execution of the
C&I SOP Agreement, the project or the affected portions thereof will be
disallowed.
Entergy Arkansas will not reimburse any customer for any costs incurred by
participating in the C&I SOP, including costs of preparing the Initial Project
Application and/or Final Project Application, reviewing or executing the C&I
SOP Agreement, or preparing and submitting Installation or Savings Reports.
Back to Top
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PROGRAM ENROLLMENT
All submissions for Entergy Arkansas' Large Commercial and Industrial Standard
Offer Program (C&I SOP) must be completed and submitted via e-mail no
earlier than 12:00 p.m. NOON, central time, on Friday, January 18, 2008
. Entergy Arkansas will date-stamp and log all program materials as they are
received. Faxed submittals are not acceptable. Submissions received
prior to 12:00 p.m. NOON, central time, on Friday, January 18, 2008
will not be eligible for the program.
After January 18, 2008, program funds are available on a first come, first
served basis until program funds all funds are reserved per the program rules.
As of March 31, 2008, 45% of the program funds are reserved. Program funds
are still available for both commercial and industrial customers.
CLICK
HERE to download an Initial Project Application.
E-mail Address to submit the Initial Project Application on or after 12:00
Noon, central time, 1/18/08 is:
LargeSOPEAI@clearesult.com
A hard copy of the Initial Project Application with the signed Initial Project
Application Agreement must be received by Entergy Arkansas within 10 working
days of the e-mail submission, addressed to:
Program Administrator – EAI Quick Start Programs
Large C&I SOP 6929 JFK Blvd., #20-167 North Little Rock, AR
72116-5339
Checklist (IPA Checklist)
A short list of all the items required in an Initial Project Application along
with instructions for sending. Use this form as a cover sheet for the Initial
Project Application.
Project Profile (IPA.1, IPA.2)
Project-wide information including a project summary and project savings
estimates. This profile consists of multiple Excel® worksheets and all
worksheets are required in the Initial Project Application.
IPA Agreement
A list of terms and conditions required as part of the Initial Project
Application.
It is the sole responsibility of the customer to ensure that Entergy Arkansas
receives applicable program materials at the designated address by close of
business on the applicable due date. Customers should retain proof of delivery
(such as return receipt for certified, registered or overnight mail) for all
program materials submitted.
APPLICATION CONFIDENTIALITY
Entergy Arkansas' C&I SOP is subject to oversight by the Arkansas Public
Service Commission, which may request a copy of any C&I SOP materials that
Entergy Arkansas receives. Sensitive company and project information submitted
by the customer to Entergy Arkansas, such as financial statements and project
costs, will be treated confidentially to the fullest extent possible and will
not be provided directly to outside parties other than the APSC. Entergy
Arkansas will have no liability to any customer or other party as a result of
public disclosure of any submittals.
FALSE, MISLEADING OR INCORRECT INFORMATION
Entergy Arkansas reserves the right to discontinue its evaluation of all
submittals from any customer who submits false, misleading or incorrect
information. If an evaluation is discontinued under these circumstances,
Entergy Arkansas will return all of the customer's submittals.
Back to Top
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
NEXT STEPS
After the customer's Initial Project Application has been approved, the
customer moves on to the next steps; which include:
-
Final Project Application
-
C&I SOP Agreement
-
Installation Report
-
Savings Report
FINAL PROJECT APPLICATION
The Final Project Application is
comprised of Microsoft® Excel® worksheets. Completion instructions are
included on the forms. Please submit your Final Project Application in both
electronic and hard copy formats.
CLICK
HERE to download a Final Project Application
Electronic copies of the Excel® worksheets may be e-mailed to:
LargeSOPEAI@clearesult.com
A hard copy of the Final Project Application with the signed Final Project
Application Agreement must be received by Entergy Arkansas within 10 working
days of the e-mail submission, addressed to:
Program Administrator – EAI Quick Start Programs Large C&I SOP 6929
JFK Blvd., #20-167 North Little Rock, AR 72116-5339
Checklist (FPA Checklist)
A short list of all the items required in a Final Project Application along
with instructions for sending. Use this form as a cover sheet for the Final
Project Application.
Project Profile (FPA.1, FPA.2, FPA.3)
Project-wide information including a project summary, project savings amounts
and calculations, and a measurement and verification plan. This profile
consists of multiple Excel® worksheets; and all worksheets are required in a
Final Project Application in addition to any applicable attachments.
Site-Profiles (FPA.4)
An Excel® worksheet containing customer and site information.
FPA Agreement
A list of terms and conditions required as part of the Final Project
Application.
Calculation Tools and Data Forms (FPA.5, FPA.6, FPA.7, FPA.8, FPA.9)
Tools for Project Measures with Deemed Savings:
The following tools/forms may be used to calculate detailed information about
retrofitted equipment that have savings based on Deemed Savings. Download and
complete only those that apply to the project.
Tools/Data Forms for Project Measures without Deemed Savings:
The following tools/forms may be used to calculate detailed information about
additional retrofitted equipment that do not have savings based on Deemed
Savings. Download and complete only those that apply to the project.
C&I SOP AGREEMENT
The standard contract is executed following Entergy Arkansas' approval of the
customer's Final Project Application. The terms and conditions are the same
for every customer. Entergy Arkansas will not entertain any proposed
modifications to the C&I SOP Agreement.
Click
here to download the C&I SOP Agreement. The Entergy Arkansas C&I SOP
Program Administrator will originate the C&I SOP Agreement with specific
incentive and kW amounts expected from the project. Customers must return the
signed agreement to Entergy Arkansas within 15 days to:
Program Administrator – EAI Quick Start Programs Large C&I SOP 6929
JFK Blvd., #20-167 North Little Rock, AR 72116-5339
INSTALLATION REPORT
Within 30 days of the completion of installation of a project's energy
efficiency measures, the customer must submit an Installation Report, which
documents the measures that have actually been installed and which describes
any changes to the project since the approval of the Final Project
Application. The form of the Installation Report is similar to that of the
Final Project Application but is intended to reflect actual measure
installations and not anticipated ones. Not all of the Microsoft® Excel®
worksheets that make up the Installation Report are required. Please read the
descriptions and notes to learn which ones are mandatory and which are not.
Further, customers need only fill in those sections of the forms that contain
project and site information that differ from what was submitted on those same
sections in the Final Project Application. Please also note that signatures
and attachments are required in the Installation Report. Customers provide
these with the hard copy submittal. Please submit your Installation Report in
both electronic and hard copy formats.
CLICK
HERE to download the Installation Report
Electronic copies of the Excel® worksheets may be e-mailed to:
LargeSOPEAI@clearesult.com
Send a complete hard copy along with supplemental materials and signatures, to:
Program Administrator – EAI Quick Start Programs Large C&I SOP 6929
JFK Blvd., #20-167 North Little Rock, AR 72116-5339
Checklist (IR Checklist)
A short list of all the items required in an Installation Report along with
instructions for sending. Use this form, which is a single Excel® worksheet,
as a cover sheet for the Installation Report.
Project Profile (IR.1, IR.2, IR.3)
Project-wide information that includes a project summary, project savings
amounts, and calculations and a measurement and verification plan. These are
multiple Excel® worksheets; all worksheets are required in an Installation
Report in addition to any applicable attachments.
Site-Profiles (IR.4, IR.5)
Site-Specific customer and site information. Note a customer-signed
installation affidavit is required as an attachment to this section.
Equipment Surveys
Updated equipment survey forms must be completed if the actual equipment
installed differs from the equipment listed in the approved Final Project
Application. Use the equipment survey forms in the Final Project Application,
and if this information has not changed, the customer should refer to the
Final Project Application.
SAVINGS REPORT
The Savings Report documents the results of a project's measurement and
verification activities and, once approved by Entergy Arkansas, forms the
basis for the customer's final incentive payment. A customer's Savings Report
is due within 30 days following the close of its project's Performance Period.
CLICK
HERE to download the Savings Report
The Savings Report is made up of a short Microsoft® Excel® form along with all
measurement data and associated analysis.
Please submit your Savings Report in both electronic and hard copy formats.
Electronic copies of the Excel® worksheets may be e-mailed to:
LargeSOPEAI@clearesult.com
A complete hard copy, along with supplemental materials and signatures, should
be sent to:
Program Administrator – EAI Quick Start Programs Large C&I SOP 6929
JFK Blvd., #20-167 North Little Rock, AR 72116-533
Back to Top
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MEASUREMENT & VERIFICATION
The purpose of measurement and verification (M&V) is to establish the
potential of a project's measures to lower peak demand and to determine the
actual savings produced by those measures.
Entergy Arkansas has designed the Large C&I Standard Offer Program to
encourage electric energy efficiency projects. Accordingly, demand savings
credit will be allowed for new equipment that exceeds a relevant industry
minimum efficiency standard, where applicable. The equipment efficiency
standards listed below shall be enforced for projects submitted to the Large
C&I Standard Offer Program:
|
Equipment Table Type
|
Applicable Baseline
|
|
Standard
Cooling Equipment
|
IECC 2003 (minimum installed efficiency)
|
|
Lighting
Standard Fixture Wattage
Maximum building wide lighting power density in Watts/square feet
|
Retrofit – Based on 1992 EPACT and AR Standard Fixture Wattage Table
New Construction – ASHRAE 90.1-2001 Lighting Power Density and AR Standard
Fixture Wattage Table
|
|
Motor
Standard Efficiencies
|
EPACT 1992 (for motors less than 200HP)
|
In the Large Commercial & Industrial Standard Offer Program (C&I SOP),
customers are responsible for planning and conducting any M&V activities
necessary for their projects. Entergy Arkansas offers three M&V approaches for
customers to use when developing their M&V activities:
-
Deemed Savings
-
Simplified M&V
-
Full M&V
The deemed savings approach can be applied specifically to the measures shown
in the section below as long as no unusual conditions exist. For example,
chiller loads must not be more than 20 percent process related, and projects
must not incorporate significant deviations from typical chiller operation
practices (e.g. non-standard chilled water or condenser water set points, ice
production during off peak hours, changes in chiller sequencing, etc.). A
customer may choose to use the deemed savings approach if applicable. No
short-term testing or long-term metering is required.
A customer may also choose to use site-specific data and either the simplified
or full M&V approach, as applicable, depending on the variability of the
building loads. The guidelines for simplified and full approaches adhere to
the standards of the 1997 International Performance Measurement and
Verification Protocol (IPMVP). Customers may also recommend an M&V approach
not covered in these guidelines; however, any alternate approach must be
approved by Entergy Arkansas and adhere to IPMVP standards. For projects using
the simplified or full approach, customers are required to submit, as part of
the Final Project Application, an M&V plan that describes the specific
activities, tools and calculations the customer intends to use to determine
the projects' actual savings.
The IPMVP web site is www.ipmvp.org
.
DEEMED SAVINGS APPROACH MEASURES
-
LIGHTING EFFICIENCY
1.1. Lamp and Ballast Replacements
1.2. HID Fixture Replacements
1.3. Hard-Wired CFLs
-
PREMIUM EFFICIENCY MOTORS
-
UNITARY AC AND HP EQUIPMENT
3.1. Air Conditioners—Air Cooled
3.2. Air Conditioners—Water and Evaporatively Cooled
3.3. Heat Pumps—Air Cooled
-
WATER CHILLING EQUIPMENT (CHILLERS)
4.1. Screw—Air Cooled
4.2. Reciprocating—Air Cooled
4.3. Reciprocating—Water Cooled
4.4. Rotary/Screw/Scroll—Water Cooled
4.5. Centrifugal—Water Cooled
SIMPLIFIED M&V
The simplified M&V approach uses stipulated values for data such as operating
hours and equipment efficiencies, thereby reducing the need for certain types
of field monitoring. They have been developed for common measures, which must
meet certain criteria for the simplified approach to be applicable.
Full M&V
The Full M&V approach uses a higher level of rigor than the simplified M&V
approach; it involves the application of end-use metering, billing regression
analysis or computer simulation. Customers must use a full M&V approach for
measures that do not meet the criteria for a simplified M&V approach. Entergy
Arkansas has developed general guidelines for the full M&V approaches, and
customers will need to adapt them to their specific projects.
To view the Simplified and the Full M&V guidelines, click
here.
Site Inspections
Over the course of a project, Entergy Arkansas conducts two site inspections.
A baseline inspection is performed before the Standard Offer Program Contract
is executed, and a post-installation inspection is performed following the
customer's submission of the Installation Report.
Baseline Inspection
Entergy Arkansas will contact the customer and complete the pre-inspection
within 10 days of the execution of the Standard Offer Program Contract. The
purpose of this inspection is to verify the following:
• The accuracy of the equipment survey. For most measures the accuracy of the
equipment quantity and nameplate information is verified. For lighting
measures, the requirement for acceptance is that the total error of the
installed demand of the sample must be within +/- 5 % of the total demand
submitted on the survey form.
-
The M&V plan (if applicable) is appropriate for the measure, and the necessary
M&V activities are being performed.
-
All existing equipment listed in the Final Project Application is still in
place and operational.
-
New equipment installation, or preparation for installation, has not begun.
Post-installation Inspection
This inspection, conducted by Entergy Arkansas within 30 days of its receipt
of a complete Installation Report, verifies the following:
-
The equipment specified in the standard offer program contract has been
installed and is operating as described in the approved Final Project
Application. For most measures the accuracy of the equipment quantity and
nameplate information is verified. For lighting measures, the requirement for
acceptance is that the total error of the installed demand of the sample must
be within +/- 5 % of the total demand submitted on the survey form.
-
The M&V plan (if applicable) is being followed in accordance with the approved
Final Project Application.
For both inspections, the presence of at least one representative of the
customer familiar with the project and with the facility is required. When
electrical measurements are necessary, the representative is required to
perform any necessary disruptions in equipment operation, the opening of any
electrical connection boxes or the connection of current and power transducers.
If an inspection cannot be completed in a timely manner because the
representative is unfamiliar with the facility or project, the project will
fail the inspection. A project has two chances to pass each inspection type;
after failing two inspections, the customer must pay the cost incurred by
Entergy Arkansas for performing additional inspections of that type.
M&V Plan Requirements
The M&V plan describes the potential for the project to achieve peak demand
savings and describes the specific activities the customer intends to perform
to determine those savings. In general, a project-specific M&V plan should:*
-
Describe the project site and the project; include information on how the
project [reduces peak demand] and what key variables affect the realization of
savings.
-
Describe the M&V approach to be used.
-
Indicate who will conduct the M&V activities and prepare the M&V analyses and
documentation.
-
Define the details of how calculations will be made. List analysis tools, such
as DOE-2 computer simulations, and/or show the equations to be used. A
complete "path" should be defined indicating how collected survey and
metering/monitoring data will be used to calculate savings. All equations
should be shown.
-
Specify what metering equipment will be used, who will provide the equipment,
its accuracy and calibration procedures. Include a metering schedule
describing metering duration and when it will occur, and how data from the
metering will be validated and reported. Include data formats. Electronic,
formatted data read directly from a meter or data logger is recommended for
any short- or long-term metering.
-
Define what key assumptions will be made about significant variables or
unknowns. For instance: "actual weather data will be used, rather than
typical-year data," or "fan power will be metered for one full year for two of
the six supply air systems." Describe any stipulations that will be made and
the source of data for the stipulations.
-
Define how any baseline adjustments will be made.
-
Describe any sampling that will be used, why it is included, sample sizes,
documentation on how sample sizes were selected, and information on how random
sample points will be selected.
-
Indicate how quality assurance will be maintained and replication confirmed.
For instance: "The data being collected will be checked every month," or "to
ensure sufficient accuracy, results will be subjected to third-party review by
the ABC company."
-
Customers should work with Entergy Arkansas to develop an M&V plan that is
appropriate for their projects.
*1997 International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP).
Sampling Guidelines
When preparing the Final Project Application, a customer is required to
document each fixture or piece of equipment that is part of a retrofit.
Equipment with similar functional uses may be grouped together for M&V
purposes. Once the equipment has been grouped, a sample of each grouping's
equipment may be monitored and the results used to estimate the operating
hours for all of the fixtures or equipment within that group.
The table below shows how large the sample size must be to provide a reliable
estimate for varying sizes of groups. The initial sample sizes represent 80
percent confidence/20 percent precision and have a coefficient of variation of
0.5; the suggested sample sizes have been increased by 10 percent to
compensate for equipment failure or loss.
|
Group population
|
Initial sample size (80/20)
|
Suggested sample size (80/20 plus 10%)
|
|
4
|
3
|
4
|
|
5
|
4
|
5
|
|
12
|
6
|
7
|
|
16 - 20
|
7
|
8
|
|
21 - 35
|
8
|
9
|
|
36 - 70
|
9
|
10
|
|
71 - 350
|
10
|
11
|
|
more than 350
|
10
|
11
|
The customer may propose an alternative approach to determining sampling
sizes, but it must be approved by Entergy Arkansas and be based on sound
statistical principles.
Back to Top
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FAQs
-
What is the Large C&I Standard Offer Quick Start Program
The program is an Entergy Arkansas energy efficiency program designed to
provide incentives for the installation of a wide range of measures that
reduce peak demand loads in commercial and industrial facilities.
-
Who is eligible for the Large C&I Standard Offer Quick Start Program?
The Large C&I Standard Offer Quick Start Program is offered to all Entergy
Arkansas (Entergy Arkansas) retail electric customers that have a peak demand
100 kW or greater or at multiple facilities with a combined maximum demand of
at least 250 kW. A customer is defined by a single Tax ID number.
Organizations with multiple locations are thereby considered a single
customer, regardless of how many Entergy Arkansas account numbers they may
have.
-
How does a customer participate in the program?
Participating customers submit an initial application to reserve incentive
funds. Upon approval of the initial application, a final application is
submitted, and if approved, customers enter into an agreement to complete the
energy efficiency projects. Projects go through a pre- and post-installation
and inspection process that approves the energy efficiency work and allows for
incentive payments.
-
What is the maximum amount of incentive funding one customer can reserve?
No customer may reserve more than 20 percent of the total SOP Program funding.
-
What are the next steps after the Initial Project Application?
After the customer's Initial Project Application has been approved, the
customer moves on to the next steps.
-Final Project Application;
-C&I SOP Agreement;
-Installation Report; and
-Savings Report.
-
What is a project?
A project is the set of proposed or installed energy efficiency measures or
other improvements necessary to produce energy savings under the program
contained in one program application. One project may contain energy
efficiency measures at more than one customer site, as long as the customers
and sites represented in each project are similar. For example, installation
of energy efficiency measures at a chain of grocery stores would include more
than one customer but could constitute only one project. If customers or sites
are dissimilar, however, a separate application is necessary for each customer
or site.
-
How does Entergy Arkansas decide which projects to fund?
Entergy Arkansas reviews the Initial Project Applications for customer and
measure eligibility. Funds are reserved on a first-come, first-served basis
until they are fully allocated.
-
What is the Incentive? How is each project's incentive calculated?
The incentive is $230/kW. Example: A project that reduces summertime peak
demand by 50 kW. The incentive for this project would be 50 kW x $230 =
$11,500.
-
When are incentive payments made?
A project that only utilizes deemed savings to calculate peak demand savings
will receive an "Installation Payment" that represents 100 percent of the
total estimated incentive payment after the project is installed, documented
and accepted. For projects using measured savings (with M&V), a customer's
incentive payment is made in two parts. The first is within 45 days of Entergy
Arkansas' receipt of the Installation Report (IR) and a successful
post-installation inspection. At this time, 40 percent of the expected
incentive payment estimated on the IR is paid. The second incentive payment is
made after measurement and verification (M&V) activities are complete,
including submission of a Savings Report (SR). The M&V process may take as
little as 90 days or as long as 12 months, depending on the energy efficiency
measures involved in the individual projects. The second payment is for the
balance of program incentives owed to the customer, based on the level of
energy savings actually achieved by the project (up to 60 percent of the
contracted amount).
-
What is the minimum amount of demand a project must save?
Each project must be expected to save at least 20 kW on-peak from May through
September, 11 a.m. to 9 p.m., weekdays, excluding banking holidays.
-
When can projects be combined or aggregated into a single application?
Different project sites may be combined into one Initial Project Application
(IPA) if the sites have identical proposed energy efficiency measures, similar
functions and similar operating conditions. For example, several sites of a
chain of hardware stores could qualify as one project. Dissimilar sites (i.e.,
those that receive different energy efficiency measures or have different
operating characteristics) may not be combined into a single project. An
example of two dissimilar sites would be an office building and a school, even
if both sites included the installation of the same measure, such as a chiller.
-
What types of energy efficiency measures are eligible for incentives?
The program is designed to allow a wide range of energy efficiency measures
and technologies to receive funding after proper measure and verification.
Certain types of measures are excluded from receiving funding under this
program.
-
How are actual energy savings determined?
Actual energy savings are determined through measurement and verification
(M&V). For the C&I Program, three levels of M&V rigor are used to estimate the
amount of energy savings achieved by the programs:
-The Deemed Savings approach uses stipulated savings data for a particular
energy efficiency measure taken from past DSM programs or other industry data;
no short-term testing or long-term metering is required;
- Simple M&V involves short-term testing or simple long-term metering but
relies chiefly on manufacturer's efficiency data and pre-set savings
calculation formulas to determine savings; and
- Full M&V refers to any M&V activities that represent a higher level of
detail than the simple M&V or deemed savings approaches, including stipulated
savings based on short-term information, metered savings of equipment or
systems, whole building billing analysis and calibrated computer simulation.
The level of M&V rigor required for a particular project depends on the type
of equipment being installed and its operating characteristics. For example,
all energy savings for lighting lamp and ballast replacements can be
determined using deemed savings. More complex project measures require more
M&V.
-
Who is responsible for measurement and verification (M&V) activities?
The customer must perform any M&V required for a project; this may involve
metering equipment energy consumption, monitoring operating hours and other
activities. Customers may need to develop an original M&V plan for unique or
complex projects. The proposed M&V plan must be included as part of the Final
Project Application (FPA). Entergy Arkansas will hire a third-party M&V
contractor to facilitate and assist customers in the design and execution of
M&V plans.
-
How is the baseline energy consumption determined?
Pre-installation monitoring may be needed to measure energy savings for some
types of energy efficiency measures. In addition, the actual baseline energy
consumption will need to be adjusted to reflect the applicable federal or
industry efficiency standards (such as ASHRAE 90.1, NEMA, ENERGY STAR®, etc.)
to determine the correct incentive amount. For some types of energy efficiency
measures, such as a constant speed chiller replacement, the baseline energy
consumption is actually determined by a minimum efficiency standard in
conjunction with some post-installation data so that no pre-installation
monitoring is necessary.
-
When can a proposed project be installed?
A project cannot be installed until the baseline equipment can be verified by
Entergy Arkansas; any necessary pre-installation monitoring is completed, and
a Standard Offer Program Contract between Entergy Arkansas and the customer
has been executed.
Back to Top
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PROGRAM CONTACTS
Entergy Arkansas Program Manager
Richard Smith Entergy Arkansas
Program Implementation Contractor
CLEAResult Consulting
ProgramAdminEAI@clearesult.com
Back to Top |